Running a business is often a joint endeavour. But what happens when a shareholder dispute disrupts the relationship so severely that continuing the business together is no longer possible? Family conflicts, fundamental disagreements about the future of the company, a deadlock in decision-making or a serious breakdown of trust can leave shareholders firmly opposed to one another. Fortunately, there are several ways to resolve such a dispute.
Not every shareholder dispute needs to end up in court. In many cases, a solution can be reached through negotiation, mediation or a structured exit process. At Vandelanotte Law, we favour an amicable solution wherever possible. Case law and legal doctrine also emphasise the importance of exploring reasonable options for resolving shareholder disputes amicably.
However, when the relationship has broken down permanently and no workable amicable solution can be found, the Belgian Code of Companies and Associations (BCCA) provides a legal mechanism known as the shareholder dispute resolution procedure.
This procedure makes it possible to achieve a definitive separation between shareholders through the courts. In this way, a prolonged dispute can be brought to an end and further damage to the company can be prevented.
The shareholder dispute resolution procedure allows shareholders of an unlisted private limited company (BV/SRL) or public limited company (NV/SA) to seek a definitive solution to a deadlocked shareholder dispute before the president of the Enterprise Court.
There are essentially two procedures: exclusion and withdrawal. Both are intended to separate the shareholders, but they differ in terms of who initiates the procedure and who is ultimately required to acquire the shares.
In an exclusion procedure, one or more shareholders ask the court to order another shareholder to transfer their shares to them. To bring such a claim, the claimant shareholder or shareholders must meet certain participation thresholds:
For a BV/SRL: the claimant shareholder or group of shareholders must hold at least 30% of the voting rights or profit rights.
For an NV/SA: the claimant shareholder or group of shareholders must hold at least 30% of the voting rights, or shares whose nominal or fractional value represents at least 30% of the capital.
In a withdrawal procedure, the situation is reversed. A shareholder asks the court to require one or more fellow shareholders to acquire their shares. Unlike the exclusion procedure, no minimum participation threshold applies to withdrawal. This means that a minority shareholder can also bring a withdrawal claim.
In both exclusion and withdrawal proceedings, the claimant shareholder must demonstrate legitimate grounds justifying a forced separation. A simple disagreement is not sufficient. There must be facts or circumstances that make continued cooperation between the shareholders impossible or seriously disrupt it.
The court will always assess the specific circumstances of the case and consider which solution is most appropriate. An important consideration is often which shareholder is best placed to continue the business and safeguard its continuity.
When shareholders separate through a dispute resolution procedure, one question inevitably arises: what are the shares worth and at what price should they be transferred?
Preparing for this valuation debate is often underestimated, even though the valuation of the shares can have a decisive impact on the final outcome of the proceedings. A thoroughly substantiated valuation, prepared with the appropriate legal and financial expertise, not only strengthens the case but can also contribute to a more efficient resolution of the dispute.
The court is not required to appoint a court expert. If sufficiently objective and reliable information is available, the court can determine the price of the shares itself.
Case law is also placing increasing emphasis on procedural efficiency. This means that lengthy and costly expert investigations are avoided where possible if the dispute can be resolved on the basis of the available evidence.
It is advisable to invest at an early stage in a thorough analysis of the company and a legally substantiated valuation of the shares.
Strong preparation not only creates a better negotiating position, but can also significantly reduce the duration and cost of court proceedings.
At Vandelanotte Law, we work closely with the accountants, statutory auditors and valuation specialists of the Vandelanotte group. This ensures that the legal arguments and financial analysis are aligned from the outset.
A shareholder dispute requires more than legal expertise
A shareholder dispute resolution procedure affects the very heart of a business. In addition to legal arguments, commercial interests, family sensitivities and financial considerations also play an important role.
Thanks to our many years of experience in corporate disputes, we assist clients both in negotiations and in court proceedings involving the exclusion and withdrawal of shareholders. We not only help you build a strong legal case, but also advise you on the strategic decisions that may determine the future of your business.